Her Cousin Was Carrying Away Grandma’s Recipe Chest — Then Leah Realized Her Sister Had Been Making Decisions for Her Without Asking
PART 2
* * *
Lunch did not improve anything.
Evelyn had made ham sandwiches because she always made too much food when she wanted people to stop talking. Amy stayed long enough to eat half of one, then left without the cedar chest and with a promise to come back when “the United Nations had finished negotiating.”
Nora did not laugh.
Leah sat at the dining table with a legal pad she had brought for room measurements. She turned it to a clean page and wrote three headings: ITEM, OWNER’S CHOICE, WHO WAS TOLD WHAT.
Nora looked over. “Seriously?”
“Yes.”
“You are not at work.”
“That’s why I’m not charging anybody.”
Evelyn shot Leah a look that said Please.
Leah softened her voice. “Mom, did you tell Amy she could have the recipe chest?”
“I told Nora I thought Amy would use it.”
“Did you tell Nora I didn’t want it?”
Evelyn hesitated. “I thought you didn’t.”
“Did I tell you that?”
“No.”
“Okay.”
Nora pushed her plate away. “You’re cross-examining her now.”
“I’m asking Mom what she remembers saying.”
“You know what? Fine. Ask me.”
Leah turned the pad toward herself. “Who wrote Amy’s name on the chest?”
“I did.”
“Based on what?”
“Based on a conversation with Mom and what you’ve been saying for five years.”
“What have I been saying for five years?”
“That you don’t want stuff.”
Leah stared at her.
Nora threw up a hand. “You don’t. Every time we talk about this house, you say Mom needs to get rid of things. You got rid of half your house after the divorce. You gave away Dad’s old desk. You donated Grandma’s china cabinet.”
“I donated the china cabinet because it did not fit in my apartment and nobody else wanted it.”
“You said it was just furniture.”
“It was just furniture to me.”
“Exactly.”
“No. Not exactly.”
The kitchen clock ticked so loudly Leah could hear the second hand catching every mark.
She looked around the dining room. The table itself had come from a furniture store in 1989, but the room had absorbed so many family events that everyone called it “Grandma’s table” even though Grandma June had never owned it. A burn mark under the linen runner came from Nora setting down a casserole dish without a trivet at Thanksgiving in 2002. One chair leg still had a strip of felt Leah’s father had stapled on when the hardwood floor was refinished.
Objects carried stories because people put stories into them. That did not mean every person carried the same story.
Leah tapped the pad. “What else have you told people I don’t want?”
Nora leaned back. “I don’t have a transcript.”
“The blue tape suggests you have a system.”
“It’s a preliminary sort.”
“How preliminary?”
“Leah, stop.”
“How many people are coming today because they think I already released something to them?”
Evelyn said, “Nobody else is coming today.”
Nora’s eyes moved to her mother.
Leah caught it.
“Who is coming tomorrow?”
